Switching from Store-Bought to Homemade Dog Food

Many pet owners in the United States are considering homemade dog food. They want to control what goes into their dog’s diet and better meet their dog’s specific needs. Homemade dog food means meals made at home with whole-food ingredients, instead of just buying commercial kibble or canned food. These meals can be either cooked or served raw. Each method has its own safety and nutritional points to consider.

This guide will show the benefits of cooking for your dog. It will tell how to create balanced recipes, switch your dog safely, and get advice from vets or canine nutritionists. You’ll learn how to make dog food at home, keep it safe, budget wisely, and solve common problems that might come up when switching.

Many dog owners in the U.S. make the switch for clearer ingredient labels, fewer allergic reactions or stomach issues, or to customize meals based on their dog’s age, weight, and how active they are. Basically, a good diet needs the right amount of protein, fats, carbs, vitamins, and minerals for dogs.

This article is here to help owners thinking about switching. It gives helpful tips but doesn’t replace advice from a vet. Before changing your dog’s diet dramatically, it’s smart to talk to a vet. This ensures your dog gets everything he needs during and after moving to homemade meals.

Key Takeaways

  • Switching from store-bought to homemade dog food lets you control what your dog eats and the quality of those meals.
  • Benefits of homemade dog food include better digestion and knowing exactly what’s in your dog’s meals.
  • Whether you choose to cook or serve raw dog food, it’s important to plan carefully for your dog’s safety and nutritional needs.
  • Changing to homemade dog food should be done with advice from a vet and a well-thought-out plan.
  • A balanced diet for home-cooked dog meals needs the right amount of proteins, fats, carbs, vitamins, and minerals.

Why Consider Homemade Dog Food: Benefits for Health and Wellness

Making meals at home lets you know exactly what’s in them. This is key for picking the right proteins like chicken or fish, and the best carbs like oats or sweet potatoes. You can also choose healthy fats like olive oil. The upside? You steer clear of the unknown stuff often found in store-bought foods from brands like Hill’s Science Diet and others.

Knowing what and how much goes into your dog’s food is crucial. You pick the recipe, giving pets with food issues what they really need. This way, tracking all the nutrients they get is a breeze, unlike trying to guess the contents of “meat by-product”.

Some dogs get better digestion and nicer coats with homemade meals. These recipes are simpler and cleaner, helping calm their stomachs. Owners often see their dogs having more consistent stools and energy.

Food sensitivities in dogs can be hard to spot. With homemade food, you can use single-protein meals to find what’s causing the problem. Chicken, beef, and certain grains are usually the bad guys. Trying different proteins, like rabbit, might help some pets feel better.

Homemade food means you can tailor meals for your dog’s needs. Puppies need more protein, while older dogs might need less food but more joint support. Active dogs need more calories. You can make sure each meal fits their life stage and activity level.

When you make your own dog food, managing how much they eat is easier. You can change recipes to help your dog lose or gain weight, or deal with health issues. Always do this with a vet’s advice, especially for dogs with special dietary needs.

Trying homemade dog food and watching how it goes can show you its true value. Done right, it can make your dog’s digestion better and lessen allergies. And you get to make food that’s just right for your furry friend’s age and how active they are.

Switching from Store-Bought to Homemade Dog Food

Choosing to switch your dog’s food is a big decision aimed at improving their health and ingredient quality. It’s important to calmly assess current food issues and routines before changing. This approach ensures your goals are realistic and helps prevent quick decisions that might harm your pet.

Signs your dog may benefit from a switch

Watch for clear signs it’s time to change your dog’s diet. Issues like ongoing vomiting, diarrhea, or loose stools suggest food-related problems. Also, constant scratching, flaky skin, lots of shedding, or ear infections could mean the current food isn’t right for your pet.

Red flags include not wanting to eat, dog’s coat becoming dull, or slow recovery from sickness. Some problems may be health-related, not food. Always consult a vet before changing your dog’s diet.

Assessing your lifestyle and time commitment

Making your dog’s food at home requires planning, shopping, cooking, and safe storing. The amount of time you’ll spend making food depends on your approach. You might cook in large batches 1–2 times a week to save time. Daily, you’ll need 5–10 minutes to portion and reheat meals.

Think about your cooking skills, how much freezer space you have, and if you need more containers. If you’re short on time or space, consider other options. These include freeze-dried foods, lightly cooked meals, or pre-made fresh foods from brands like The Farmer’s Dog and Nom Nom.

How to set realistic expectations and timelines

Be practical about the timing when starting homemade dog food. You might notice better coat or stool quality in 2–8 weeks. Changes in weight or overall health could take longer. Transition your dog’s diet slowly over 7–14 days to avoid upsetting their stomach. Section 5 outlines how to mix foods gradually.

Visit the vet for a check-up and blood tests before making any big diet changes, especially for young, old, pregnant, or sick pets. Good planning is crucial when switching foods. It ensures your dog stays healthy as you adjust their diet.

Building Balanced Homemade Recipes

A sunlit kitchen counter showcases an array of balanced homemade dog food recipes. In the foreground, a wooden cutting board displays freshly chopped vegetables, lean proteins, and whole grains. In the middle ground, glass bowls brim with nutrient-rich superfoods like sweet potatoes, quinoa, and blueberries. Trailing into the background, shelves hold jars of wholesome supplements and natural preservatives. Warm, soft lighting casts a comforting glow, hinting at the nourishing, homemade goodness within each recipe. The scene exudes a sense of care, quality, and a deep commitment to canine health and wellbeing.

Making meals safe and full of nutrients requires attention. It’s important to pick recipes meant for grown-up dogs. And, talk to a vet nutrition expert if unsure. Focus on getting the right amounts of protein, fats, and carbs, along with vitamins and minerals. Also, make sure the ingredients are safe for your dog.

Dogs need good animal protein and special amino acids to stay healthy. Foods like cooked chicken, turkey, lean beef, and salmon are great. They also need fats, like omega-3 and omega-6, for energy and a shiny coat, found in fish oil or flax. Carbs and fiber help with their digestion, coming from foods like brown rice and sweet potatoes.

Core nutrition: protein, fats, carbs, vitamins, and minerals

Getting the balance right is crucial. Aim for a diet with mostly protein, then fats, and finally carbs and fiber, based on how active your dog is. It’s also important to have the right amounts of calcium and phosphorus for their bones. And don’t forget about vitamins A, D, E, B-complex, and minerals like iron and zinc.

Stick to proven recipes or use a dog-specific vitamin to hit all nutrient goals. Be exact with how much of each ingredient and supplement you use. It’s easy to miss out on important nutrients, especially when making food at home, if the balance is off.

Safe human foods and common ingredients to avoid

Some safe foods for dogs include plain cooked meats, eggs, pumpkin, yogurt, carrots, green beans, rice, and sweet potatoes. These are often used in homemade dog food. Offer them as main parts of their diet.

Stay away from chocolate, xylitol, grapes, onions, nuts, alcohol, and raw bread dough. Bones can be dangerous if cooked and raw diets have risks. Talk to your vet about these and keep things clean if you choose raw food.

Using supplements properly to fill nutritional gaps

Supplements can make homemade meals complete. Popular options are calcium from eggshell or chalk, fish or algae oil for fats, and dog-specific vitamins. Probiotics are also good for their stomachs.

Pick known brands and match the supplement amount to your dog’s size and age. Working with a vet nutrition expert can ensure you’re using supplements safely. This way, you keep your homemade dog food balanced and healthy.

Category Examples Notes
High-quality proteins Cooked chicken, turkey, lean beef, salmon, cooked eggs Provide essential amino acids; rotate sources for variety
Healthy fats Fish oil, flaxseed oil, small amounts of olive oil Supply omega-3 and omega-6 for skin and brain health
Carbs & fiber Brown rice, sweet potato, peas, pumpkin Support digestion and steady energy
Vitamins & minerals Dog multivitamin blends, calcium carbonate, ground eggshell Essential for bone, immune, and metabolic function
Safe human foods Plain yogurt (small amounts), carrots, green beans Good as supplements or treats within balanced recipes
Foods to avoid Chocolate, xylitol, grapes/raisins, onions, garlic, macadamia nuts Toxic; can cause severe illness or death
Supplements Fish oil, probiotics, canine multivitamins Use products formulated for dogs and follow dosing

Step-by-Step Transition Plan

Switching your dog to home-cooked meals needs patience and a clear plan. A smooth change avoids stomach problems and lets you see how your dog reacts to the new food.

Start slowly when changing your dog’s diet. Here’s an easy 7–14 day plan that suits most dogs.

  • Days 1–3: 25% homemade, 75% current food.
  • Days 4–6: 50% homemade, 50% current food.
  • Days 7–9: 75% homemade, 25% current food.
  • Day 10 onward: 100% homemade.
  • For dogs with sensitive stomachs or trying new foods, lengthen each phase by 2–3 days.

Gradual mixing schedule to avoid digestive upset

Add small amounts step by step, so your dog’s stomach gets used to it. If you’re switching proteins, take it slower to cut allergy risks. Make sure food portions stay the same and avoid new treats during this time.

Monitoring appetite, stool, and energy levels

Check on your dog’s health every day. Look for changes in how much they eat, the look and frequency of their poop, and any signs of vomiting or gas. You might notice their poop is a bit soft at first, but that’s normal.

Write down what your dog eats, and when, and note anything unusual. Take pictures of their poop if something worries you. Also, see if their energy is too low or high, as this could mean something’s not right.

When to pause or adjust the transition

If your dog has diarrhea for more than 2-3 days, throws up, stops eating for a day, gets very thirsty or tired, it’s time to stop and think.

Go back to their old food and talk to a vet if problems don’t go away. You might need to tweak the new food plan, like cutting back on fat or testing for allergies.

Keep watching how your dog does and stick to regular feeding times. Taking small steps can help your dog happily switch to new food without trouble.

Consulting Your Veterinarian and Canine Nutritionists

Making homemade food for your dog requires planning and expert advice. Schedule a vet visit to talk about your dog’s diet and health. This meeting is key to ensuring your dog gets all the nutrients needed and highlights any health issues.

Make a list of your dog’s current food, treats, and any supplements. Include your dog’s age, weight, how active they are, and any health problems. Discuss important nutrients like calcium and phosphorus, especially if you’re avoiding bones in meals. For issues like kidney disease or diabetes, get advice tailored to your dog’s needs.

It’s smart to get blood tests to safely tweak your dog’s diet. Older dogs or those with long-term health issues should get special tests to check their organs. If your dog’s weight or energy has changed for no clear reason, thyroid tests might be suggested. Dogs that might not get enough taurine should have specific tests too.

Puppies, moms-to-be, nursing dogs, and those on special diets need extra check-ups. After changing diets, get blood tests to make sure everything is balanced. These tests help catch any problems early and make switching diets safer.

To find an expert in dog nutrition, ask your vet for recommendations. Look in the American College of Veterinary Nutrition directory for certified specialists. You might also want to check out pet nutrition services that have vets and nutritionists working together.

Stay away from so-called “experts” without real training in vet care or nutrition. Telehealth with qualified professionals can offer recipe advice and ongoing support. Confirm the qualifications of any nutritionist you consider, ask for examples of their work, and find out how they track results.

Step What to Prepare Why It Matters
Initial vet consultation List of foods, supplements, age, weight, medical history Identifies contraindications and informs safe recipe choices
Baseline testing CBC, chemistry panel, thyroid, breed-specific nutrient tests Detects existing issues and sets a monitoring benchmark
Follow-up bloodwork Repeat panels 6–12 weeks after diet changes Confirms balance and catches nutrient shortfalls early
Finding a specialist Referrals from your vet; ACVN directory; credential checks Ensures advice comes from a board-certified canine nutritionist
Use of telehealth Verified tele-nutrition providers that include vets Offers convenient access to recipe reviews and follow-up

Meal Prep, Storage, and Food Safety

Making meals at home requires easy systems for health and time savings. Proper meal prep, good labeling, and hygiene help safely cook large batches. These tips are useful whether you cook weekly or make food to store and use later.

Detailed meal prep of homemade dog food. A glass container filled with various healthy ingredients like cooked chicken, sweet potatoes, brown rice, and steamed vegetables. The food is neatly arranged in sections, with a scoop and a spoon nearby, conveying an organized, nutritious, and carefully prepared meal. Soft, natural lighting illuminates the scene, highlighting the vibrant colors and textures of the ingredients. The overall atmosphere is one of care, attention to detail, and a commitment to providing a wholesome, homemade meal for a beloved pet.

Batch cooking tips and portioning

Cook dog food in batches once or twice a week. Stick to the same recipes for accurate calorie and portion control. Divide food by weight or calorie needs into single servings in sealed containers or bags.

Mark each package with the date, calories, or portion size. Active puppies may need 2–3% of their body weight in food. Adults need 1.5–2.5%, changing based on activity and shape. Start here and adjust with calorie counts and a body score.

Safe refrigeration and freezing practices

Keep your fridge under 40°F (4°C). Put cooked food in closed containers and use within 3–4 days. Freeze meals at 0°F (-18°C). Homemade food stays good for 2–3 months in the freezer.

Defrost food in the fridge overnight. Don’t leave thawed food out too long. Gently warm food before serving and avoid microwave uneven heating by stirring and checking its temperature. Throw away any leftover food if out for over two hours.

Preventing bacterial contamination and spoilage

Be very clean with raw or cooked food. Wash hands and surfaces well, and keep meat and veggies separate. Always clean tools and containers to avoid germs spreading.

Cook meats till they’re safe, like poultry to 165°F. If feeding raw, know the risks of Salmonella and Listeria to pets and people. Especially if your home has kids, elderly, or anyone with weaker health, be extra careful and clean.

Keep homemade food away from strong smells and in portions that fit your feed schedule. With clear labels, the same recipes, and focusing on safety, it’s easy to store and freeze homemade dog food. For store-bought homemade dog food, use the same care for freshness.

Cost Comparison and Budgeting Tips

Making your dog’s meals at home leads to questions about cost and how to plan. Here’s a practical guide to figure out monthly expenses, smart ways to save money, and how to keep nutrition high without spending too much.

Estimating monthly costs vs. commercial diets

Choosing a balanced homemade diet depends on the type of protein, needed supplements, and what things cost in your area. For a dog weighing between 30–50 pounds, homemade meals might cost about $60–150 every month. In contrast, commercial dog food can cost anywhere from $30–120 per month based on the brand and its quality.

Services like The Farmer’s Dog, Nom Nom, and Ollie might charge $150–350 monthly. These services provide balanced meals and convenience, helping pet owners see the cost difference between commercial and homemade meals.

Ways to save without sacrificing nutrition

Pick cheaper proteins like chicken thighs or ground turkey, and mix them up with eggs and canned sardines. This keeps your dog’s protein intake high while saving money.

Instead of fancy ingredients, use trusted supplements to fill in any nutritional gaps. Coupons and memberships at places like Costco or Sam’s Club can also help reduce costs.

Cooking in large batches and using portion control prevents waste. Planning your meals around sale items lets you save money while still giving your dog balanced meals every week.

Seasonal shopping and bulk-buying strategies

Buy large pieces of meat when they’re on sale, cut them into portions, and freeze what you don’t immediately need. Buying in bulk, like getting rice, oats, and frozen veggies, lowers the cost per meal and ensures you always have staples on hand.

Choosing frozen vegetables saves money and keeps nutrients intact, especially when fresh ones aren’t in season. Make sure to label everything with the date and what’s inside, rotate your stock regularly, and avoid freezer burn.

Watch for the best deals by comparing prices and joining store loyalty programs. Planning your meals around what’s in season helps you save on dog food costs while keeping your dog’s meals diverse and balanced.

Category Typical Monthly Cost (30–50 lb dog) Cost Drivers
Homemade (economy proteins) $60–90 Chicken thighs, eggs, rice, seasonal veg, basic supplements
Homemade (premium proteins) $100–150 Beef or fish, specialty supplements, organic produce
Commercial kibble (budget to mid) $30–70 Store brands, larger bag sizes, fewer fresh ingredients
Commercial kibble (premium) $80–120 High-quality proteins, grain-free options, branded formulas
Fresh pet food delivery $150–350 Pre-portioned, balanced recipes, home delivery convenience

Troubleshooting Common Issues After Transition

Switching to homemade dog food has its ups and downs. We will cover how to solve common issues, soothe upset tummies, address picky eating, and notice signs of missing nutrients. Quick tips will help you act swiftly to keep your dog happy and healthy.

Digestive upset: causes and remedies

Digestive problems can happen if changes are made too quickly or if meals are too rich. They can also occur when trying new foods or if there are harmful bacteria. Sometimes, health issues can look like food problems.

To fix this, transition more slowly over one to two weeks and cut back on fats for loose stools. A simple meal of boiled chicken and rice for a day or two may help, along with plenty of water.

Adding a probiotic that contains Lactobacillus might aid digestion. If vomiting or diarrhea doesn’t stop after a few days, or if your dog seems dehydrated, see your vet.

Dealing with picky eaters and maintaining variety

For picky eaters, try warming the food to enhance its smell. Mixing in a bit of their old kibble can also encourage eating.

Keep meals interesting with different proteins and textures, such as turkey or salmon. Setting regular meal times and not leaving food out all day can boost their appetite.

If your dog keeps being picky, it could be due to pain or illness. See your vet to check for these issues. If the problem stays, your vet can suggest ways to make food more appealing.

Recognizing nutrient deficiencies and when to act

Keep an eye out for signs of nutrient shortage like a dull coat or dry skin. These might mean your dog needs more zinc or essential fats. In puppies, weak bones or not growing well could mean they’re not getting enough calcium.

Being tired, having pale gums, or not wanting to exercise could mean your dog is anemic. This might be due to a lack of iron or vitamin B12. Weak muscles or heart issues in some dogs could indicate a taurine deficiency, though it’s uncommon.

Have regular vet check-ups and blood tests if you’re worried. If tests show a lack of nutrients, get advice from a vet who specializes in animal nutrition. They can adjust your dog’s diet with specific supplements.

  • Quick checklist: slow the switch, hydrate, use bland meals, add probiotics.
  • Picky eater tips: warm food, rotate proteins, create meal routines.
  • Deficiency cues: coat changes, growth problems, lethargy, neuromuscular signs — get bloodwork.

Conclusion

Switching to homemade dog food can let you control ingredients better. It’s great for dogs with sensitive stomachs. You can also make food that fits your dog’s age, size, and how active they are.

Homemade dog food can make your dog’s coat shinier and improve their appetite. But, you need to plan well to make sure their meals are balanced. Adding the right supplements and checking in with your vet is key.

When changing your dog’s diet, talk to your vet first. Get blood tests for pets that might be at risk. Pick recipes that are balanced or get help from a vet who knows about pet nutrition. Make changes slowly, keep an eye on your dog’s eating and bathroom habits. Also, be careful about how you store their food to keep germs away.

If you’re short on time, you might think about fresh-food services or diets approved by vets. Think about what your dog needs, what you can afford, and how much time you can spend on making food. With the right plan and advice from pros, many dog owners in the U.S. have switched to homemade food. They do it to help their dogs stay healthy and happy for a long time.

FAQ

What exactly is “homemade dog food” and how does it differ from commercial kibble or canned diets?

Homemade dog food is food you make for your dog using fresh ingredients instead of buying dry or wet food from the store. It can include cooked or raw ingredients like chicken, rice, and vegetables. It’s different because it’s made by you, and you know exactly what’s in it. But, making sure it has all the nutrients your dog needs can be tricky without some expert advice.

Why might I consider switching my dog from store-bought food to homemade meals?

People switch to homemade dog food for many reasons. Some want to know exactly what their dog is eating. Others have dogs with allergies or special dietary needs that store-bought food can’t meet. Homemade food might also make your dog’s fur shinier and their stools better. However, it’s important to plan meals carefully and check with your vet to ensure your dog’s diet is balanced.

What signs suggest my dog could benefit from a diet change?

If your dog often has tummy trouble, itches a lot, or has a dull coat, a diet change might help. Also, look out if they’re not excited about their current food or have skin problems. Always check with a vet first to make sure these aren’t symptoms of a bigger health issue.

How much time and effort does homemade feeding require?

Making homemade dog food takes some planning and a bit of time in the kitchen. If you cook in batches once or twice a week, daily feeding won’t take much time. You need to know your way around the kitchen and have space in your fridge or freezer. For those who are too busy, there are companies like The Farmer’s Dog or Nom Nom that make fresh dog food for you.

How do I build a balanced homemade recipe my dog can thrive on?

Your homemade dog food recipes need to have the right mix of protein, fats, and carbs. Plus, they must include all the vitamins and minerals your dog needs. Sometimes, you’ll have to add supplements to make sure the food is complete. A vet with nutrition training can help you create a perfect menu.

What human foods are safe for dogs, and which ones are toxic?

Dogs can eat lots of human foods like cooked meats, eggs, and certain veggies and grains. But keep them away from chocolate, grapes, onions, garlic, and foods with xylitol. Never give them cooked bones because they can break and hurt your dog. Be careful with raw diets, as they might contain harmful germs.

Do I need supplements if I feed homemade food?

Yes, homemade food usually needs extra nutrients. Adding calcium, omega-3s, and a multivitamin formulated for dogs is common. Make sure the amounts are right for your dog’s size and health. Choosing high-quality supplements is important. Always ask your vet for advice on what your dog needs.

How should I transition my dog from commercial to homemade food without causing digestive upset?

Change your dog’s diet slowly over about two weeks. Start with a mix that’s mostly their old food, then gradually increase the amount of homemade food. If your dog has a sensitive stomach, take even more time. Watching how your dog reacts during this time is key.

What should I monitor during and after the transition?

Keep an eye on how much your dog eats, the quality of their stool, and if they vomit or have gas. Check their energy and the condition of their skin and coat too. It’s normal for their stool to be a bit soft at first, but if diarrhea or vomiting lasts, call your vet.

When should I pause the transition or seek veterinary help?

If your dog has diarrhea for more than two days, vomits a lot, stops eating, seems dehydrated, or is very tired, stop the new diet. Go back to the old food and talk to your vet right away.

What medical checks should I do before switching diets?

Talk about your diet plan with your vet, mentioning your dog’s current food, treats, and any health issues. Dogs that are old, very young, pregnant, or have health problems might need a blood test first. Your vet can tell you if seeing a dog nutrition expert is a good idea.

How do I find a qualified canine nutrition professional?

Your vet can recommend a qualified dog nutritionist. You can also look up certified nutrition experts online. Just make sure they have real credentials and know about dog nutrition.

How should I handle meal prep, storage, and food safety?

Cook dog food in big batches and store it in containers in the fridge or freezer. Keep everything very clean to avoid germs. Label everything so you know when it was made. This keeps your dog safe and healthy.

Is raw feeding safe for my dog and my household?

Feeding your dog raw food comes with risks because of germs like Salmonella. It’s especially risky for people and pets with weak immune systems. If you go raw, talk to your vet, keep things very clean, and choose ingredients carefully.

How much does homemade feeding cost compared to commercial diets?

Homemade dog food costs depend on what you make it with and any supplements you add. It might cost between to 0 per month for a mid-sized dog. Store food varies in price, and fresh-food services are convenient but cost more.

How can I save money while keeping meals nutritious?

To save money, pick cheaper proteins and buy in bulk. Use frozen veggies, and don’t forget eggs and sardines for extra nutrients. Watch for sales to swap proteins. Shopping at stores like Costco can help you save.

What are common problems after switching and how do I troubleshoot them?

If your dog gets an upset stomach or doesn’t want to eat, you may need to change how fast you switch foods. Sometimes, a simple diet or less fat helps. If your dog looks unwell or has fur issues, see your vet for advice.

How do I portion meals and determine how much to feed?

Figure out how much your dog needs based on their size and how active they are. There’s a basic rule for how much food to give, but watch your dog’s weight and adjust as needed. Your vet can help you get this right.

Are there special considerations for puppies, seniors, or dogs with health issues?

Yes, puppies and older dogs have different needs, and sick dogs need special diets too. Before making changes, get a vet checkup and possibly some tests. A dog nutritionist can then help you create the best meal plan.

How often should I have my dog’s diet and health re-evaluated after switching?

Check in with your vet a few months after changing your dog’s diet to make sure they’re doing well. If you have a dog with special needs, you might need to go more often or do extra tests.

Can I combine homemade food with commercial diets or fresh-food services?

Mixing homemade and store-bought dog food can work well. It makes meal planning easier and can still meet your dog’s nutritional needs. Just check with your vet to ensure the mix is right for your dog.
Published in November 13, 2025
Content created with the help of Artificial Intelligence.
About the author

Amanda

Content writer specialized in creating SEO-optimized digital content, focusing on personal finance, credit cards, and international banking, as well as education, productivity, and academic life with ADHD. Experienced in writing articles, tutorials, and comparisons for blogs and websites, always with clear language, Google ranking strategies, and cultural adaptation for different audiences.